Thanksgiving and Native Americans: History, Remembrance, and the Practice of Gratitude

As Thanksgiving approaches, one question comes up every year: How do Native Americans celebrate Thanksgiving? Do they celebrate it at all?

There is no single Native American perspective on the holiday. Native people and families have different histories, experiences, and traditions, and they respond to Thanksgiving in different ways. For some, it is a day of mourning. For others, it is a time for remembrance, family, or gratitude.

To understand those differences, we need to look honestly at the history behind the holiday. The familiar story of Pilgrims and Native people sharing a peaceful harvest feast leaves out much of what happened before and after that moment. A more complete understanding of Thanksgiving makes room for both the painful history of colonization and the values of gratitude, family, and community that remain important today.

I can share my own perspective and how my family approaches the holiday, but I cannot speak for all Native people. Even in a house full of Native people, I cannot assume I know what everyone is thinking.

The Thanksgiving Story: What History Leaves Out

The Thanksgiving story most Americans learn is often highly simplified. It usually describes Pilgrims arriving in New England, receiving help from Native people, sharing a harvest meal, and establishing a lasting tradition of friendship and cooperation.

There are elements of truth in that story, but the familiar version leaves out important context.

The English settlers arrived in a region that was already home to thriving Native communities. This was not an empty wilderness inhabited by a few scattered groups of nomadic people. Native nations had established villages, cultivated land, maintained political relationships, and developed extensive systems of trade, agriculture, and resource management.

The Wampanoag and neighboring Native communities had their own histories, territories, and ways of life long before the Pilgrims arrived.

Native people did help the English settlers survive. Tisquantum, commonly known as Squanto, and other Native people shared food, knowledge, and agricultural practices. There were efforts to establish relationships and maintain peace. These acts of generosity and diplomacy were real and deserve recognition.

But those relationships existed within a much larger context. English settlement meant the displacement of Native people from their lands, villages, and resources. Native communities were being asked to accommodate newcomers who increasingly claimed territory that was already theirs.

The story was never as simple as a peaceful gathering between two groups meeting on equal terms.

From Early Cooperation to Conflict

There were periods of relative peace and efforts to maintain relationships, particularly between the Wampanoag and English settlers. But the English population grew rapidly, and settlement expanded across the region.

By 1675, there were approximately 90 English villages in what is now the northeastern United States. The growing settler population placed increasing pressure on Native lands and communities.

Metacomet, a prominent Wampanoag leader whom the English called King Philip, faced the challenge of protecting his people's interests and maintaining their independence amid this expansion. Eventually, violent conflict erupted in what became known as King Philip's War.

The conflict was devastating for Native communities. It followed earlier violence against neighboring peoples, including the Pequot and Narragansett, and resulted in widespread death, displacement, and destruction.

Metacomet was killed, and his body was subjected to public desecration. His head was displayed at Plymouth for years. His wife and son were sold into slavery and sent to the Caribbean.

For some Native communities, the violence of this period was genocidal. The consequences were not limited to the immediate loss of life. Native nations also experienced the loss of land, political power, community stability, and the ability to sustain their ways of life.

This history is an essential part of understanding Thanksgiving. We cannot tell an honest story about early cooperation without also acknowledging the violence and dispossession that followed.

How Do Native Americans Observe Thanksgiving Today?

Native people do not all observe Thanksgiving in the same way. Some view it as a day of mourning. Others use it as an opportunity to remember ancestors and reflect on Native history. Still others gather with family, share meals, and give thanks.

For many people, these responses are not mutually exclusive.

One example of remembrance takes place in Plymouth, Massachusetts. Descendants of the English settlers and descendants of the Wampanoag and neighboring Native communities gather for an annual observance known as a Day of Mourning. The gathering recognizes the complicated history of the region and creates space to remember what happened to Native people.

These conversations can be difficult. Descendants of settlers may confront feelings of guilt or shame about the actions of their ancestors. Native descendants may grapple with painful memories of dispossession, violence, and the lasting effects of colonization.

The gathering offers an opportunity to face that history rather than avoid it. Remembering honestly can help people understand the past and consider what responsibility they have in the present.

For Native communities, remembrance is not simply about looking backward. It is also about recognizing the realities that continue today, including the loss of ancestral lands and the challenges Native nations face in protecting their communities, cultures, and sovereignty.

How My Family Celebrates Thanksgiving

In my own family, Thanksgiving is an opportunity to gather. I have a few days away from work, the kids may be home from college or taking a break from school, and we have time to be together.

We try to be mindful of the history surrounding the holiday. We do not want to ignore the painful experiences of Native people or pretend that the familiar Thanksgiving story tells the whole truth.

At the same time, we give thanks for the things we value: the company of one another, our lives, our relationships, and the opportunity to contribute to making the world a better place.

For us, remembrance and gratitude can exist together. We can acknowledge the suffering of Native ancestors while appreciating the people and opportunities in our lives today.

That is my family's approach. Other Native families may have different traditions and feelings about the holiday, and those perspectives deserve respect as well.

Gratitude and Healing Are Practices

I believe happiness is not simply a destination we reach. It is something we practice. Some days we do better than others, but the more we practice, the more capable we become of experiencing happiness.

The same is true of gratitude. We do not become grateful simply by deciding once that we should be. We practice noticing what we have, appreciating the people around us, and recognizing the good in our lives.

You cannot go to the gym once, have one great workout, and expect to be strong for the rest of your life. Strength comes from returning and practicing. Gratitude works in much the same way.

Healing and reconciliation require that same commitment.

We do not get to healing by skipping the hard feelings. We do not get to reconciliation by skipping the work of reconciling. We have to be willing to understand what happened, acknowledge the harm, listen to people whose experiences differ from our own, and take responsibility for what comes next.

Thanksgiving can be an opportunity to do some of that work. It can be a time to ask what we remember, what we have learned, what we are grateful for, and how we might contribute to a more just and compassionate future.

An Opportunity for Honest Reflection

The Thanksgiving holiday carries different meanings for different people. For some, it brings family and celebration. For others, it brings grief and painful memories. Many people experience a mixture of emotions.

We do not need to erase those differences or force everyone into one shared interpretation of the holiday.

Instead, we can use this season to learn more about Native American history, recognize the experiences of Native nations, and reflect on the responsibilities we have to one another. We can appreciate the generosity and knowledge Native people shared with early settlers while also acknowledging the dispossession and violence that followed.

Most importantly, we can understand that gratitude and accountability belong together. Being thankful for what we have does not require us to ignore how history shaped the world we live in. And remembering painful history does not prevent us from building meaningful relationships and working toward a better future.

The work of gratitude, healing, and reconciliation is ongoing. Thanksgiving can be one opportunity to practice.

Recommended Resources

Books by Anton Treuer

Additional Resources