Why Native Health Data Cannot Be Separated From History
When we look at health statistics for American Indian and Alaska Native people, we have to ask a deeper question than simply, “Why is this happening?”
The United States has profound disparities in health outcomes for Indigenous people, including disparities in life expectancy. But statistics alone can create a misleading picture if we do not understand the history and circumstances behind them.
The first question should not be, “What is wrong with Native people?”
It should be, “What happened to Native people?”
That shift matters.
Native communities are not all the same. About half of enrolled tribal citizens live away from reservations, and the majority of people who self-identify as Native live away from reservations as well. Urban, suburban, rural, and reservation communities can have very different experiences.
There is no single Native experience.
But there is a shared history that helps explain many of the health challenges Indigenous communities face today.
Native Health Is Not a Reflection of Indigenous Identity
One of the most important things to understand is that these health disparities are not evidence of something inherently wrong with being Indigenous.
They are deeply connected to the colonial experience.
Historically, Indigenous communities developed sophisticated systems of food production, environmental stewardship, physical activity, social connection, spirituality, and community care. These practices supported what we might now call relational health—the understanding that individual wellbeing is connected to relationships with family, community, land, culture, and the natural world.
Colonization disrupted those systems.
When we remove people from their lands, separate children from their families, suppress their languages, disrupt traditional food systems, undermine community structures, and impose economic systems that create poverty and dependency, we should expect consequences.
Those consequences do not disappear simply because the policies themselves eventually change.
The Disruption of Indigenous Ways of Life
The history of Native American health cannot be separated from the history of federal Indian policy.
The boarding school era is one example. Indigenous children were forcibly removed from their families and communities and placed in institutions designed to assimilate them. The explicit goal expressed by figures such as Richard Henry Pratt was to destroy Indigenous identity and replace it with an imposed cultural identity.
Children were separated from their families, languages, cultures, and communities.
Many experienced neglect, abuse, illness, and death.
The consequences extended far beyond the children who attended those schools. Trauma affected families and communities across generations.
This is why Native American history is not simply a subject from the past. It continues to shape contemporary health, education, family structures, language use, economic conditions, and community wellbeing.
Cultural Disruption Has Health Consequences
Culture is not just something we perform at special events.
Culture can be a health resource.
Traditional foods, language, ceremonies, extended family relationships, time spent on the land, physical activity, spirituality, and community responsibilities can all contribute to wellbeing.
When those systems are disrupted, communities lose important protective factors.
This is one reason Indigenous language revitalization matters so much.
The Ojibwe language carries relationships and ways of understanding the world that are difficult to separate from Ojibwe culture itself. Reclaiming language is therefore not simply an educational project. It can also be part of rebuilding identity, belonging, intergenerational relationships, and community health.
Food, Economics, and the Modern Health Crisis
Health disparities also have an economic dimension.
Consider the modern food environment. In some communities, nutritious foods can be expensive or difficult to access, while highly processed foods are cheaper and more readily available.
A bag of apples can cost substantially more than inexpensive processed foods.
That is not simply a matter of individual choice.
When economic systems make healthy food difficult to obtain, communities face structural barriers to healthy living.
The disruption of traditional food systems compounds the problem. Indigenous peoples historically relied on foods such as wild rice, fish, berries, game, maple sugar, and other locally harvested foods.
These were not simply sources of calories. They were embedded in cultural practices, relationships, seasonal cycles, and knowledge systems.
Replacing those systems with commodity foods high in refined carbohydrates, sugar, and unhealthy fats has had serious consequences for many Native communities.
The rise of diabetes and other chronic health conditions cannot be understood without considering these changes.
Relational Health Is a Missing Piece of the Conversation
Modern health conversations often focus heavily on the individual.
What are you eating?
How much are you exercising?
What choices are you making?
Those questions have value, but they are incomplete.
Indigenous perspectives remind us that human beings exist within relationships.
Are you connected to family?
Do you have a community that supports you?
Do you have a meaningful relationship with the land?
Can you participate in cultural practices?
Do you speak your language?
Do you have a sense of purpose and belonging?
These are not minor questions.
They are part of health.
When colonial policies disrupt those relationships, the resulting health consequences should not be interpreted as individual failures.
Avoiding the Stereotype of the "Poor Indian"
Reservation communities are sometimes portrayed as though poverty and despair define all Native people.
That is both inaccurate and harmful.
Native people live in cities, suburbs, rural communities, and reservations. Native people work in every profession. Native families have vastly different economic circumstances and life experiences.
Even within a single tribal nation, there can be tremendous diversity.
Reducing Native communities to their worst statistics reinforces stereotypes rather than helping us understand the underlying causes of disparities.
We need to look at the complete picture.
Starting the Story in the Right Place
One of the biggest problems with discussions about Indigenous health is where the story begins.
If we begin with the current statistics, we can easily conclude that Native communities simply have more problems.
But if we begin earlier—with land dispossession, forced removal, boarding schools, cultural suppression, environmental disruption, economic exploitation, and the destruction of traditional food systems—we begin to understand the conditions that produced the statistics.
The question changes from:
“Why can't Native people get their lives together?”
to:
“What systems and historical experiences created these conditions, and what can we do to change them?”
That is a much more productive question.
Rebuilding Health Through Culture and Connection
The good news is that history does not have to determine the future.
Indigenous communities are rebuilding.
Language revitalization is happening. Traditional food systems are being reclaimed. Ceremonies are being practiced. Young people are learning from elders. Communities are reconnecting with the land.
These efforts are not simply acts of cultural preservation.
They can be acts of healing.
When we strengthen the Ojibwe language, we strengthen relationships between generations. When young people learn traditional practices, they gain connections to their communities. When families harvest traditional foods together, they strengthen both cultural knowledge and relationships.
This is Indigenous education at its best: education that helps people understand who they are, where they come from, and how they are connected to one another.
We Need to Tell the Whole Story
Native health statistics matter.
But statistics are not the whole story.
If we want to understand why disparities exist, we need to understand Native American history. We need to examine the effects of colonial policies. We need to recognize the disruption of Indigenous languages, cultures, economies, food systems, and relationships.
And we also need to tell the story of resilience.
Native communities are not simply collections of problems. They are communities with extraordinary cultural knowledge, languages, traditions, relationships, and strengths.
The work ahead is not about returning to some imaginary past.
It is about reclaiming the cultural, relational, and community resources that have always helped Indigenous people thrive and bringing them forward into the future.
If we want healthier Native communities, we need to understand the history that shaped them—and invest in the cultural connections that can help heal them.
Recommended Resources
Anton Treuer — The Cultural Toolbox
Explore culture as a practical resource for identity, relationships, community wellbeing, and navigating contemporary life.
The Cultural Toolbox
Anton Treuer — The Language Warrior's Manifesto
Learn about Indigenous language revitalization and the importance of carrying the Ojibwe language and cultural knowledge into future generations.
The Language Warrior's Manifesto
Ojibwe Language Resources
Resources for learning and supporting Ojibwe language revitalization.
Anton Treuer's Speaking Engagements
Learn more about presentations on Indigenous education, Native American history, cultural understanding, language revitalization, and community wellbeing.
Speaking Engagements
Anton Treuer on YouTube
Explore additional teachings and conversations about Ojibwe language, Native American history, Indigenous education, culture, health, and community.
Anton Treuer on YouTube